An entity or person has a conflict of interest when their personal (or self-serving) interests collide with their professional obligations or responsibilities. Such a conflict arises when a business or individual has a vested interest, such as money, position, knowledge, connections, or reputation, which calls into doubt their ability to act, judge, or make decisions objectively.
A conflict of interest occurs in business when someone puts their interests ahead of those of their employer or another stakeholder organisation or when they, in some other way, take advantage of their position for personal gain.
Did you know? Wipro fired more than 300 of their staff in 2022 on conflict of interest charges as they were engaged in moonlighting jobs.
Conflict of Interest
A conflict of interest arises when a person's claims, such as those related to their family, friends, finances, or social standing, potentially impair their judgment, choices, or actions at work. Government organisations take conflicts of interest seriously enough that they are governed.
A conflict of interest may also occur when a person must answer to two different parties or groups whose demands clash—in this situation, helping one person or group might unknowingly and sometimes knowingly harm the other. For instance, auditors have a fiduciary obligation to investors who depend on the financial reports they verify. However, the businesses whose words the auditors assess directly employ and compensate the auditors. The obligation of loyalty an auditor has to investors may conflict with the requirement to satisfy the company, which is also the auditor's customer, and with the latter's wish to appear as a reliable investment. Therefore, if we want to be ethical individuals, we must actively avoid circumstances we can gain from betraying others.
To derive a better understanding, let"s understand the word interest first. So what exactly is meant by the word Interest?
Interests can encompass a wide range of obligations, duties, commitments, and beliefs, including:
- legal or contractual responsibilities
- commitment to family and friends, and ties with them
- Professional obligations
- business objectives
For instance, you could be devoted to your family's business and the firm for which you work. You may be in a conflict of interest if the objectives of those two firms directly contradict.
Types of Interest
The four types of possible interests that an individual could have are as follows:
- Direct interests comprise a person's self-interest, family responsibilities, and private commercial interests.
- Indirect interests are the interests of the individual's connections on a personal, familial, and professional level.
- Financial interests: These encompass everything with monetary worth, such as goods or services supplied, business transactions, or stock ownership.
- Non-financial interests cover interpersonal connections, kinship, and other possible biases.
Examples of Conflict of Interest
To address conflicts of interest, it is important for people and entities to disclose any potential conflicts to the appropriate parties and to take steps to manage or eliminate the conflict. In the workplace, conflicts of interest are frequently problematic. Most people have heard the phrase "It's who you know, not what you know" at some point.
- Coworkers have expressed dissatisfaction about how a manager's relative always receives the most significant increase or assignment.
- Coworker who arrives at second job 20 minutes early each day and leaves work 20 minutes early.
- Starting a firm that competes with your current job
- Recommending a customer invest in a business controlled by your spouse
- Hiring an unqualified friend or family
- We may have witnessed coworkers take presents from potential clients.
Even though these scenarios are significantly distinct, they are all considered ‘conflicts of interest.’
When is a Conflict of Interest most likely to occur?
Conflicts of interest happen most frequently when requirements and interests collide. Because of the nature of connections against policies of organisations or regulations at the federal and state levels, several forms of conflicts of interest may arise. People are prone to prejudice (having an unfair preference) due to trivial considerations like friendship, food, or flattery. They can also be persuaded to choose by the prospect of gaining money, status, or authority. Conflicts can arise when someone makes or influences a choice for their own unfair, unethical, or even unlawful personal advantage. What you choose to do in each of those circumstances is crucial. Do you let your relationships with your family, friends, money, or insiders influence your decisions? If you do, you could be breaking both policy and state law.
We all have interests outside of work that may affect how we conduct ourselves professionally and our choices. There can be a perception that a conflict of interest impacts our choices, even if we never take action. Think about this instance. Your boss is now the department director. The college has recruited his daughter-in-law as a new supervisor, but she does not answer him. The supervisor could be the most significant person for the job, and it's possible that the new department director had nothing to do with her hiring. Even if her employment complied with all rules outlined in our Employment of Relatives policy, the circumstance seems strange, and staff members may believe that something about her getting the job was unfair or morally questionable.
What is a conflict of interest policy?
A conflict of interest policy is meant to ensure that the organisation has a procedure under which the affected party will inform the governing body about all the pertinent details regarding the issue when actual or prospective conflicts of interest occur. It describes the steps taken by the firm and its workers if a worker's interests clash with those of the organisation they work for.
A conflict of interest statement states the company's policy to guarantee that neither board members nor workers make choices that might serve their interests.
Disclosure of Conflict of interest
When addressing actual and potentially perceived conflicts of interest, transparency becomes crucial. Conflict of interest is a perception when someone watches something (behaviour or activity) and draws a conclusion. A perceived conflict of interest does not always become one. Disclosure is the only proven way to determine if a situation actually involves a conflict of interest or is only possibly perceived to do so.
Conflicts of interest are situations when appearance and reality are equally significant. This is why it's crucial to disclose conflicts of interest. Most organisations have embraced disclosure as a more formal and well-documented approach to handling conflicts of interest. The disclosure process aims to support the workforce's accountability for (explain or defend) their actions and choices while promoting transparency. Although it doesn't turn a perceived issue into a genuine one, disclosure may assist in resolving it.
On the other hand, admitting to an actual conflict of interest does not end it; instead, it helps bring it to light so that it may be appropriately resolved. Instead of keeping a conflict of interest to oneself and putting oneself in a moral or legal bind later, it is crucial to reveal both real and prospective conflicts of interest so that others can assess the situation and reach a judgment. Due to the lack of an independent or unbiased point of view, the person cannot decide whether or not there is a conflict.
The ancient adage "When in doubt, ask" is quite wise when trying to resolve conflicts of interest. Asking is not harmful, but not asking might significantly harm a person, an organisation, or both. To ensure that we remove any actual or potential conflicts of interest, it is better to be open and held to account.
Common Types of Conflicts of Interest
Conflicts of interest can come in many different shapes and include a range of personal and professional interests. There are numerous cases of conflicts of interest that are quite particular, yet some of them happen more frequently than others. Read further to know the most typical types of conflicts of interest:
The most prevalent form of conflict of interest in business is self-dealing. It happens when a management-level professional or any high-ranking official accepts a transaction from another firm that is advantageous to the manager but detrimental to the business or the clients. They could benefit personally at the firm's expense by using resources or access the company provides. It stands for an unlawful act, and individuals who perform it risk legal action, fines, and job termination.
For example, a manufacturing company's chief financial officer, or CFO, has discovered that the business intends to buy Arnold Production. Before announcing the transaction, the CFO utilises this knowledge to strengthen their stock holdings. In addition to being unethical, this insider trading is also against the law.
2. External Employment:
Having many jobs in the same industry might create a conflict of interest. A conflict of interest situation arises if working for one firm grant you access to confidential information that another company does not, and you utilise that information for your second employment. This is especially true if you've signed a non-disclosure agreement.
A practice of giving preferential treatment or showing bias towards family or friends is known as nepotism. In this scenario, a person in a position of authority in a company gives favours, advantages, or job openings to family members based more on the relationship than on real qualifications.
As an illustration, the employment of a new employee for a rental company's customer service division falls under the purview of the human resources manager. The child of the HR manager is one of the applicants. The HR manager chooses to hire their child despite him having less industry experience than the other top applicants.
Another extremely frequent conflict of interest is gift-giving. It occurs when a manager or official of a corporation accepts a present from a customer or another comparable sort of individual. Typically, businesses mitigate this risk by outlawing presents from clientele to specific workers.
5. Manipulation of stocks:
Stock manipulation is a very particular but extremely significant conflict of interest. Manipulation of stocks refers to the act of intentionally attempting to influence the price of a stock through deceptive or fraudulent means. Market manipulation refers to the act of intentionally manipulating the supply and demand for a stock in order to influence its price.
6.Overpayment of wages:
Excessive remuneration happens when a company pays a worker significantly more than others for similar tasks or equivalent responsibilities in other firms. An overpayment of wages is when an employee receives more pay than they are entitled to. This can occur for a variety of reasons, such as an error in payroll, a mistake in calculating hours worked, or a change in an employee's pay rate. The employee often has a high position and significant political or social influence.
Conflicts of interest can also arise in other contexts, such as when a government employee has financial interests that could influence their decisions or when a lawyer represents clients with conflicting interests.Some organisations have policies in place to prevent or mitigate conflicts of interest, such as requiring employees to disclose their financial interests and prohibiting employees from engaging in certain activities that could create a conflict.
Follow Khatabook for the latest updates, news blogs, and articles related to micro, small and medium businesses (MSMEs), business tips, income tax, GST, salary, accounting.