If GST is implemented on petrol and diesel in India, it will result in a more straightforward tax structure, replacing numerous tax systems with one. It could benefit firms to receive input tax credit benefits, lessening the tax cascading effect. However, it can initially cause fuel prices to rise, which might affect consumers and companies and call for mitigating measures like reduced GST rates or subsidies.
This article aims to analyse the potential effects of implementing GST on the prices of these fuels and examine the advantages and disadvantages of this taxation change. This exclusion has resulted in inconsistent tax rates and price variations among states. By examining the reach of GST and assessing its potential effects on petrol and diesel prices, we can enhance our comprehension of the consequences for consumers, the economy, and the overall tax structure in India.
Did you know? GST in India is one of the largest tax reforms in the country's history, unifying multiple indirect taxes levied by the central and state governments into a single tax.
Understanding GST and Its Scope
The Goods and Services Tax (GST), or indirect tax system, was implemented in India. Its primary objective is establishing a unified tax system by eliminating indirect taxes. This expense change focuses on the stockpile of labour and products and plans to smooth out the tax assessment process throughout the country. By comprehending the extent to which GST applies, its applicability to diverse goods and services, and the exemption of petrol and diesel, we can better understand the potential implications of incorporating these essential commodities under the GST framework.
The Pros of Imposing GST on Petrol and Diesel
Imposing GST (Goods and Services Tax) on petrol and diesel can bring several benefits. Here are some pros:
A. Price Rationalisation
Price rationalisation refers to the process of bringing uniformity and consistency to prices. In the context of GST on petrol and diesel, price rationalisation would involve establishing a standard tax rate across states, eliminating the current disparities in fuel prices. Different states impose varying taxes on petrol and diesel, resulting in price fluctuations and inconsistencies. Implementing GST on these fuels aims to create a standardised tax structure that leads to price rationalisation. This would ensure that consumers pay a consistent price for petrol and diesel, regardless of location, promoting transparency and reducing price differentials.
B. Boost to Revenue
Forcing GST on petroleum and diesel can help the public authority generate income. By including these fundamental products under the GST system, a more extensive duty base can be laid out, prompting expanded charge assortments. The extra income created can be used for foundation advancement, social government assistance programs, and other significant drives. Not only would this increase in revenue contribute to the overall expansion of the economy, but it would also provide the government with additional resources to meet the requirements of its citizens. The public authority can reinforce its monetary position and back different formative exercises by extending the assessment base through GST on petroleum and diesel.
C. Simplification of Tax Structure
The imposition of GST on petrol and diesel would simplify the tax structure surrounding these essential commodities. Currently, the tax system for petrol and diesel involves multiple taxes such as excise duty, value-added tax (VAT), surcharges, and others imposed by both the central and state governments. This complex web of taxes creates administrative burdens and confusion. By implementing GST. These multiple taxes would be replaced by a single tax, streamlining the tax structure. This simplification would reduce administrative complexities and enhance transparency and make it easier for businesses and consumers to understand and comply with the tax regulations related to petrol and diesel.
Read More: GST Council Meet: Tax concessions on Medicines, No Decision on Petrol and Diesel
The Cons of Imposing GST on Petrol and Diesel
While there are potential benefits to imposing GST (Goods and Services Tax) on petrol and diesel, there are also some drawbacks to consider:
A. Inflationary Pressure
One of the concerns associated with imposing GST on petrol and diesel is the potential for inflationary pressure. If GST is implemented on these essential commodities, it could lead to an increase in their prices. As fuel is a pivotal contribution to different ventures and transportation, any ascent in fuel costs can significantly affect creation costs and the costs of fundamental labour and products. This, in turn, can contribute to inflationary pressure within the economy. It is essential to carefully assess and monitor the impact of GST on petrol and diesel prices to mitigate any potential adverse effects on inflation.
B. Revenue Loss for States
Suppose petroleum and diesel are brought under the GST system. In that case, the states might encounter a decrease in their duty income, which could influence their capacity to finance fundamental administrations like medical care, schooling, and foundation improvement. It becomes crucial to consider compensatory measures or alternative revenue-sharing mechanisms to address the potential revenue loss for the states and ensure their financial stability and ability to meet the needs of their respective populations.
C. Political and Social Implications
The installation of GST on fuel and diesel has serious political and social ramifications. Fuel costs have traditionally been a politically contentious issue in India, frequently eliciting popular outrage and protests. Any change in the tax system that influences gasoline costs can directly impact consumers' pockets and their views of government policy. Furthermore, political parties and consumer organisations may protest the application of GST on fuel and diesel, making implementation difficult for the government. Balancing the economic advantages of GST with possible social and political consequences necessitates considerable thought and efficient communication with stakeholders.
Possible Mitigation Measures
To mitigate the potential drawbacks of imposing GST on petrol and diesel, several measures can be considered:
A. Tax Slab Differentiation
One possible mitigation measure for the concerns surrounding GST on petrol and diesel is the implementation of tax slab differentiation. This approach involves establishing different tax slabs for these fuels than other goods and services. Recognising the unique nature of petrol and diesel as essential commodities, a differentiated tax structure can be designed to consider their socio-economic impact. By adopting this approach, the government can address concerns about potential price hikes and inflationary pressure while ensuring that the tax burden on consumers and businesses remains reasonable. Implementing tax slab differentiation requires careful analysis and consideration of the specific needs and dynamics of the petrol and diesel market to strike a balance between revenue generation and affordability.
B. Compensation Mechanisms
Various compensation mechanisms can be explored to mitigate the potential revenue loss for states resulting from the imposition of GST on petrol and diesel. These mechanisms can offset the financial impact on states and ensure a smooth transition to the new tax regime. Compensation measures may include revenue-sharing arrangements, where a portion of the GST revenue collected on petrol and diesel is allocated to the states. Additionally, the government can consider implementing cess or surcharges on fuel within the GST framework, allowing for specific funds to be earmarked for states to compensate for the revenue loss. Finding appropriate compensation mechanisms is crucial to maintaining the states' financial stability while implementing GST on petrol and diesel.
Read More: GST Rates & HSN Codes on Fossil Fuels - Coal, Petroleum & Natural Gas - Chapter 27
Conclusion
In conclusion, to make an informed decision regarding implementing GST on petrol and diesel, thorough analysis, consultation with stakeholders, and careful consideration of mitigation measures are necessary. Tax slab differentiation and compensation mechanisms can be explored to address concerns and minimise the potential adverse effects. Policymakers and economists need to continue discussions and engage in open dialogue to shape a tax policy that benefits all stakeholders.
Follow Khatabook for the latest updates, news blogs, and articles on micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs), business tips, income tax, GST, salary, and accounting.
